I'm going to explain in more detail how this section works and what the things that I say in it actually mean. You can read the first review of mental health in books, of the book 'The coincidence of Callie and Kayden'
If a mental health issue
is not directly mentioned in the book, I will not name it. I will
mention it if I consider it to be a mental health issue (for example
suffers a loss of memory from a traumatic event could potentially be
understood as suffering PTSD, but if PTSD is not named in the book as
such, I will not give it a name). This is because I am no therapist
or expert on psychology so I do not want to diagnose the characters.
Some posts may be about
this: about speculating what mental health issue a certain character
may have even if it is not mentioned in the book as such.
Some things will be
mentioned in the mental health issues and you may think 'that is not
necessarily problematic'. Let's give the example of: controlling
calories, random sex or going on shopping sprees. These behaviours
are not problematic per se, but can potentially become so if they are
used as mood regulators. Let's take the example of random sex. There
is nothing wrong with random sex, unless someone does it for the
purpose of making them feel better and forget other underlying
issues. If it is done for that purpose and then afterwards brings
other feelings such as shame and regret then it might be an issue. So
I'm not saying that random sex is wrong and whoever does it
immediately has to have a mental health issue (not at all), but it can be used
for that purpose.
The questions at the end of each book review are:
Therapy mentioned? This asks whether therapy is mentioned, is it considered an option to the mental health issue in the book.
Positive or negative image
of sufferer of mental health illness? This is not answering whether it is an accurate depiction of the mental health illness. I can't be sure of whether it is 100% accurate but if I feel like it doesn't feel realistic, I will definitely mention that in the review. This question is asking whether it gives a positive image of the character suffering a mental health issue. It doesn't matter that much whether he/she is bad, it's whether it's solely the illness that defines that character and if it is seen as a negative trait. For example, if someone is portrayed as evil because of their mental health issue, I will specify that under this section. I feel like some media tends to show that message, that mental health issues makes someone worse... So I think that it is an important factor to evaluate in a book containing mental health issues.
Mental health issues
mentioned: Here again, read the second paragraph of this post. I'm not diagnosing the characters!
Triggering issues? Different things can trigger different people. I will try to state the ones that I feel like could be triggering.
Rating: Following the Goodreads style, I will rate it up to 5 stars.
However many stars are colored in gold, are the rating that I have given it.
The rating is completely subjective and may have little to do with the mental health issues that are portrayed in it.
No comments:
Post a Comment